RX 5500 XT vs RX 580
The RX 5500 XT and the RX 580 compared on price, performance, VRAM and Value Score, using the current cheapest valid Amazon CA listing of each card.
Short answer: The RX 580 is the better value right now: Value Score 29 against 17.
- Performance: the RX 580 is 19% faster on our Performance Index (3.8 against 3.2).
- Price: the RX 580 is CA$83.51 (42%) cheaper, at CA$198.98 against CA$282.49.
- VRAM: both have 8 GB.
RX 5500 XT vs RX 580: specs and price
| RX 5500 XT | RX 580 | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | AMD | AMD |
| VRAM | 8 GB | 8 GB |
| FP32 | 5.2 TFLOPS | 6.2 TFLOPS |
| Performance Index | 3.2 | 3.8 |
| Price now | CA$282.49 | CA$198.98 |
| Value Score | 17 | 29 |
| Price per GB of VRAM | CA$35.31 | CA$24.87 |
| Price per Performance Index point | CA$89.64 | CA$52.95 |
Green marks the better figure in each row. Prices are the cheapest valid listing at our last check; always verify before purchasing. Affiliate disclosure.
Check the RX 5500 XT on Amazon Check the RX 580 on Amazon
Which should you buy: RX 5500 XT or RX 580?
The RX 580 is both faster and cheaper, so there is no trade-off to weigh: on today’s prices it is the better buy.
Is the RX 5500 XT better than the RX 580?
Performance: the RX 580 is 19% faster on our Performance Index (3.8 against 3.2). The RX 580 is the better value right now: Value Score 29 against 17.
Which is cheaper, the RX 5500 XT or the RX 580?
Price: the RX 580 is CA$83.51 (42%) cheaper, at CA$198.98 against CA$282.49.
Which has more VRAM, the RX 5500 XT or the RX 580?
Both have 8 GB of VRAM.
How is performance measured here?
The Performance Index is a card’s FP32 compute (TFLOPS) divided by 1.65, so an RTX 4090 scores 100. It is a measure of raw compute, not a game benchmark: real frame rates also depend on the game, the resolution, the drivers and how each brand’s architecture uses its TFLOPS, so treat gaps of a few percent as a tie and check game reviews before buying for one title. The Value Score combines the Performance Index, the current price and the card’s VRAM.